29 November 2008

Epic! Young vs Old.. Hot vs. Hot

Sheldon Souray vs. Sam Gagner



Vote via the comments, if you can even pay attention to what you are doing here.

Sorry Sam, you're not enough of a man, yet. Souray wins.

35 comments:

Sarah said...

OMG souray for sure. i love that man. so hot.

Anonymous said...

This is one of the hardest decisions of my life... why would you make the two most good looking players compete! haha

Uh... Souray... no Gagner... no Souray

Ya, I vote SOURAY.

kinger said...

Jen and I vote for Souray.

Julie said...

souray wins it all

Lord Bob said...

Souray is alone in almost all of his photos. Gagner is with people in almost all of his. That tell you something, maybe?

Wait, it gets better! Look at the first Gagner picture. Tom Gilbert, also known as "the human bowl of mashed potatoes" is in it along with two bar women with more plastic than an American automobile, and Gagner's enough to make the picture hot anyway!

Got to be Gagner.

Ida said...

Sammy, even though he makes me feel old since he's younger than me.

Cassidy said...

GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER! GAGNER!

i vote for Sammy.

d said...

SS.

marie said...

Souray...comes close to Moreau and the sadly departed Reasoner for me.

Lady_Byng said...

SHELDON!

beck said...

oh man. this is tough! they are the two hottest on the team for sure.

but i have to say sam.

Weeza said...

Souray for sure

Graham said...

Sam Gagner

ann! said...

sheldon souray!

Jody said...

Gagner

B.C.B. said...

Look at the way Souray grips that stick. He also has shoulders.

I vote Sheldon "Dapper Dan" Souray

Anonymous said...

SHELLY!

Souray all the Way

T. said...

Sheldon. Absolutely.

Sam himself says his metabolisn is never going to produce that kind of muscle definition.

Lowetide said...

Gagner. His mom is hot. I mean really, really hot, like Elizabeth Montgomery hot.

Oh yes. Sam Gagner. When he wins, let me present the award and then he can introduce me to his mom.

arrugaoil said...

Gags!!

Meg said...

Gagner!!!

Anonymous said...

Sheldon Souray

What I wouldnt do to Mr Souray...

Anonymous said...

Sheldon Souray is definately my vote

There is a pic online of him and his daughter and he is giving her a piggy back ride, it makes him even hotter...

Hottest hockey player
Hottest dad
Hottest guy to ever be on this website!

Anonymous said...

Gagner!

melanie... said...

It has to be Souray!!!

Lord Bob said...

Please, you can't give Souray credit because of his kids. And you certainly can't give it to him in a round against eighteen-year-old Sam Gagner, because that carries highly disturbing implications.

Scott said...

I vote Souray. Helping the Oilers win games is hot.

Anonymous said...

Should I get my Christmas wish, I'll be over the moon with a new Gagner retro jersey. But here in the Hot Off, Souray gets my vote. This sexy beast is playing like I thought and hoped he would. Sorry Sam.
RoliLover

word verification 'panti' lol

doritogrande said...

Souray.

I love that first picture of Gagner. He looks like a lame duck beside Gilbert and his two 'arms'

Anonymous said...

Souray for sure

kara said...

I'm going to go with Sam. He's probably having an easier time scoring off the ice...

Anonymous said...

Gagner!

Garnet said...

This showdown is nothing less than a re-enactment of David Cook vs. Archuleta on American Idol:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vxzIamlzoA

"How could they vote for that loser, that loser that doesn't shave?"

Anonymous said...

one is hot, one is cute.

Souray. No contest.

Shannon said...

Hey - isn't that blonde girl with Nilsson the same blonde girl in the second picture?

WTH? Is she a professional puck bunny (I'm not judging - just jealous!)?