20 September 2006

Day 18: A difficult choice


Welcome to day 2 of round 2. This one will prove to be a difficult choice for fans! There's MacT, who is a constant source of humourous remarks. then there's the soul of the Oilers, none other than assistant captain Ryan Smyth, who still scores goals for the team. This decision will tear families apart.

Note: I'm not trying to influence you with the massive size difference between pictures. I'm just terrible at all things computer.

Voting over. The Silver fox out foxes nitty gritty Smytty.

42 comments:

Pam (chopper) said...

hmmmmmmmmm - neither really does anything for me personally; but I would have to choose MacT in this match-up, cuz Smyth really, really, REALLY does nothing for me.

Sorry to his lovely wife, but Smyth is bordering on the side of ugly - lol.

Dominique said...

MacT has a George Clooney-esque deliciousness about him. Daddy complex insinuations aside, I have to choose him over the Mullet-that would-not-die.

sammy said...

Sorry to Ryan Smith, but I have to go with the very yummy Craig MacTavish.

D. said...

This is kind of difficult, but not really. MacT is hot. Period. Sorry, Smytty.

the Prez said...

Count me for Smyth.

grace said...

YOU'RE ALL ON NOTICE AGAIN. When I have my first born, his name isn't going to be Craig, it'll be Ryan. When people ask how I chose that name, it's going to be the story of my love for Ryan Smyth.

Passion is sexy. An Oiler is sexy. Having one's teeth knocked out by a hockey player that I DESPISE MORE THAN I DESPISE TIM HUNTER in game 3 against SJ and having to get stitched up, only to return in O/T to get an assist on the game winning goal...is all sexy to me.

Ryan Smyth, first last and always, has my vote.

Yes, MacT is funny et al and he's hilarious in interviews but I don't want someone in bed laughing, I want a hot oiler that brings passion.

Daggit said...

ah, classic as Clooney for sure. MacTavish.

allan said...

I share Grace's great love for Ryan Smyth.

However, this is supposed to be a purely shallow contest based soley on hotness, so I have to go with MacTavish.

Loxy said...

MacT is hot.

The man is aging like a bottle of fine wine - better with each passing year.

lowetide said...

Close one, but I'll go Ryan Smyth. Voting against him while in the active portion of his career is impossible.

btw, if you ever do a "best interview" hot-off Smyth wins hands down. He has a way of saying absolutely nothing over a long period without making it comfortable or informative.

He's a genious. :-)

(Yes I know I've spelled it wrong, that's the joke).

Anonymous said...

grace: I THOUGHT YOU WERE NAMING THE KID ETHAN! YOU LIED! HOW CAN YOUR CHILD GROW UP WITH A MOTHER WHO LIES!?

Oh and Smytty gets my vote. I'm voting for whoever's going to lose now. It's part of my plan while I sulk on the death of Jussi. If Lydia ever votes again, I am going to boo her outta here!

She said...

A difficult choice indeed- in my mind, the matchup could be considered unethical.

As much as I love Smyth...(Bows to LT's wisdom) MacTavish was my second favourite Oiler waaaayyyy back when. I must acknowledge the halcyion days of my youth.

Craig's still got it. And a fabulous interviewee too.

cat said...

Oh no.

No no no.

Before I change my mind - and I know I will - Ryan Smyth. I heart the mullet. And the man beneath it. Smytty is the Oilers.

"Passion is sexy. An Oiler is sexy. Having one's teeth knocked out by a hockey player that I DESPISE MORE THAN I DESPISE TIM HUNTER in game 3 against SJ and having to get stitched up, only to return in O/T to get an assist on the game winning goal...is all sexy to me."

Word.

Scarlett said...

As much as I think MacT is fabulous, it's Smitty all the way. He has so much heart, and bleeds blue and copper. He is the face of the Oil, one which I find damn handsome!

Dominique said...

I shall go with the mullet. It's beautiful as is Ryan!

hockeygirl said...

My first instinct was Smyth which surprised but then I thought about it some more and who else screams, "I'M A HOCKEY PLAYER!" more than him? Captain Canada gets my vote.

grace said...

Anonymous, the first child would have been named Ethan if Ethan starred any longer at my camera as I'm quite certain his swimmers are potent but, alas, I'm not gestating his child therefore no junior.

And HAHAHAHA...Lydia's my sister!!!!! I'll send her back here to vote for Ryan, just because she'll get a kick out of that comment.

And all mothers lie. Show me one that doesn't and I'll show you one that is lying about that.

Jordi said...

Bah that comment was me. See how I can't seem to login due to my incompetence.

I'll take Ethan then! That mother lying comment was more of a perk, I just wanted you to hand over the rights to Moreau's children.

Alana said...

All you Smytty voters are crazy. MacTavish is pure sex. Count one more vote for the coach.

J.R. Hippe said...

Coach.

afterburner said...

One more vote for the big Mac daddy.

gary b said...

put me down for MacT, aka 'the Silver Fox'.

D. said...

Heh - Silver Fox. I like that one.

Jen said...

Silver fox? Ummm no thanks. I'll take a young man over an oldie anyday! Smyth all day for me!!

Hannah said...

I love Smitty! I vote for Captain Canada.

Kas said...

Why is everyone voting for MacT? Sure, handsome man but hello, Ryan Smyth is the hardest working Oiler. Do you remember him getting his teeth knocked out in the playoofs, and then coming back to help win the game? He's a god. I vote for God, I mean Smyth!

peck said...

MacT. The mullet makes me think of rural Alberta, and that is definitely not a good thing.

mudcrutch79 said...

MacT.

penalty said...

MacT

amy said...

MacT

Loxy said...

Dear Voters,

A message from your friendly neighborhood blogmaster:

Heart is hot. But being hot is hotter.

Point taken?

Love,

Loxy!!

Scarlett said...

I still think Smitty is hotter!

Rachael said...

MacT all the way to the finals!

Black Dog Hates Skunks said...

Have to vote for my mancrush!

Smytty.

court said...

hhaaaaarrrsh.


I'm goin' on record with a vote for MacT before I think about it any more and change my mind.

Wiggler said...

Tough one - the helmetless hero vs the toothless hero.

I gotta go with the most recent hero - Smytty! Fat lips are sexy.

Loxy said...

Sorry guys, that was kinda harsh of me. I guess I'm just trying to remind us that it's a euperficiality contest. If I was voting on the rest of the intangibles, I'm sure it'd be different!

T. said...

Damn damn damn - how did I miss this one?! No that it matters now but I would have voted for Smytty.

Now and always.

Anonymous said...

MacT is the hottest Oiler there is ....he aged better than the rest from the eighties. He has a sexy,funny delicious quality about him.

Anonymous said...

Smytty's got my vote.

Anonymous said...

YOU'RE ALL DUMB!!!! (unless you like both) McT IS THE COACH AND RYAN SMYTH WAS THE ASSISTANT CAPTAIN!!!! THEY'RE BOTH GREAT AND THIS SITE IS FOR FAGGETS WHO CARE WHO IS UGLIER IN HOCKEY! THE GAME ISN'T ABOUT HOW PRETTY YOU ARE! IF IT WERE, THEN WHAT THE HELL IS STORTINI DOING IN THE NHL!!!??? FUCK YOU ALL SMYTTIE AND McT ARE BOTH MY FAV AND YOU CAN SUCK MY DOG'S COCK!

Anonymous said...

This is my version of Alanas comment:

All of you MacT voters are crazy! Smytty is pure sex! Count one more for the sexy player.